Don Pepe Steakhouse

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.4

( 16 reviews )

Steakhouses

58 US-46, Pine Brook, NJ 07058, United States

+1 9738-085-533

Don Pepe Steakhouse, a renowned brand in the dining industry, prides itself on delivering an exceptional culinary experience that captures the essence of a classic steakhouse. With a reputation built on excellence, Don Pepe Steakhouse has established itself as a go-to destination for steak lovers and connoisseurs of fine dining. Offering a wide range of delectable options, from succulent porterhouse steak to mouthwatering lobster, their menu is thoughtfully crafted to satisfy even the most discerning palates. The restaurant's commitment to quality and impeccable service creates an inviting atmosphere that keeps guests coming back. With a focus on providing an unforgettable dining experience, Don Pepe Steakhouse strives to exceed expectations and leave a lasting impression.

Amenities and More

Takeaway
Beer
Accepts reservations
Credit cards
Fast service
Small plates
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Bar on site
Brunch
Solo dining
Great dessert
Tourists
Dinner reservations recommended

Reviews

4.4/5

16 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Ron

March 22, 2024

Outstanding food, outstanding service, and old school charm. What more can you ask for? Can't wait to go back

Juan serrato

March 22, 2024

Had a nice team dinner here with the team.. We were all seated quickly and placed our orders.. the drinks came out pretty fast but were a little weak.. but the food more than made up for it. They had a live singer and dancer to perform, which was a nice touch and was not too loud.. Everybody liked their food, and these steaks are HUGE.. even the filet mignon.. like 1.5 - 2 inches thick.. so be ready.. they were all cooked to order and seasoned nicely. Not too many options for kids.. but you can always feed them off your plate..

Keith pang

March 22, 2024

Great food and service. Soft shell crabs were on special, and they were delicious. Love the fresh salad & shrimp too

Jake sager

March 22, 2024

Old steakhouse needs an upgrade. For the price, you would expect excellent food. The food was ok at best. The server was not very nice when questioned about the menu. The atmosphere was dated and worn. Seems the kitchen and wait staff don't care. Steaks were sizable, but half the table said that there was too much grizzel. I had lamb that was not quite rare when I requested medium. I'm not sure if I would return.

Tzu an chen

March 22, 2024

How anyone can give this place more than 2 Stars ⭐️ is beyond me. They must not dine out a lot except for fast food. Steaks are awful. Shell fish is Frozen not fresh.. Service leaves a lot to be desired.. Atmosphere is dingy. Only reason I gave 2 stars is the Sangria was good

Manjit goldsmith

March 22, 2024

Had to place a star, but very disappointed at new management that apparently took over Don Pepe Steakhouse!! Well you failed already….. Had reservations for an office Holiday Party, to our surprise showed up and they were closed. Called Don Pepe II and they confirmed that it was closed temporarily for renovations. Good job notifying us of this!! Don’t worry Tavern 73 next door(I highly recommend) accommodated us and we had a wonderful evening!

Lexie vela

March 22, 2024

Nice, clean restaurant with attentive staff. The garlic shrimp appetizer was good. I ordered the queen sirloin medium and it was cooked perfectly. Huge portion, I couldn't even eat half. The red sangria tasted a little watered down. The special watermelon sherbet was really good.

Ivan kunz

March 22, 2024

I went to Don Pepe for a Paella Marinera and I ended up at a great Steak House. So I had to visit Don P a 2nd time A.S.A.P. even if it meant paying 2 tolls to get there. My Dad and I shared a delicious Seafood Paella & T-Bone Steak on Christmas Eve. The food, service, and atmosphere went perfectly with the occasion for dinner.